A homeowner is backing out of his garage, forgets to open the garage door and causes a $1000 worth of damage to the door. The Car is undamaged, the homeowner has autoliability and comprehensive insurance but not collision.
The homeowner has "Condo" insurance which covers bodily injury liability, damage to the interior of the house and loss of house contents.
The local HOA has a group homeowners policy that covers structural damage to the exterior of the house, such as roof, paint, walls, fences etc that result from fire or natural disasters.
As the homeowner's negligence while driving caused the damage to his garage door, an exterior appertenance of his house, to which policy should the homeowner's claim be directed, (auto, condo or group HOA homeowner's policy)??
Does it really matter which insurance company gets the claim first given subrogation protocols between companies?
What is the key fact of this case that determines to which company the claim should be directed ?